Showing posts with label Plato. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Plato. Show all posts

Monday, 17 February 2025

Plato's Lysis (a dialogue on friendship)

Lysis (Friendship) By Plato Dramatized Audiobook - Audiobooks Dimension

Translation by Benjamin Jowett (1817 - 1893)



The dialogue starts at about 19:00 on the audio file.

Some thoughts on friendship

Please see comments in the following file relating to the dialogue.

A PDF file with highlights and brief comments can be found below:

Some additional resources



Wikipedia: Lysis (dialogue)


Some questions relating to friendship


In the Benjamin Jowett translation, there are some questions at the end of the Introduction section.  It is on the end of page 4 of the PDF file above.  We can discuss some of those questions.

In addition, we may ask the following:

  1. What are the different type of friendships?
  2. Why do people want to have friends?
  3. What are the characteristics or personalities that enable one to have more friends?
  4. Why do some people have a few good and close friends, some have many acquaintances, and some people are lonely?
  5. Is friendship between humans only? Could there be friendship between: a) human and pet/animal, b) animal and animal,  c) human and subject (e.g. philosophy, mathematics, science), d) human and activities (e.g. work, sports, art)?
  6. Philosophy means "love of wisdom".  Is that one of the most important type of friendship?
  7. What is friendship? (Please see for information the Wikipedia page on friendship.)
  8. What are the main themes explored in Lysis and what are some questions related to those themes? (See Wikipedia page on Lysis.)


Wednesday, 10 July 2024

Apology of Socrates - summary and analysis

 

"The Trial of Socrates (Plato's Apology)" by Nothing New

Summary of the Apology

The video above gives a summary of Plato's dialogue, Apology.

Analysis

The following are videos from Associate Professor Anadale:

The following are videos from Dr Gregory B. Sadler:

Some questions

To be added.

Monday, 8 July 2024

Phaedo

 

Phaedo by PLATO read by Bob Neufeld | Full Audio Book - by LibriVox Audiobooks

Full text translation

Relevant web pages 

Some questions for discussion

To be added.

Crito


 "Crito by Plato Audiobook with Text, Illustrations"- by Audiobooks Dimension

Full text translation

Relevant web pages 

Some questions for discussion


To be added.

The Apology of Socrates

 

"The Apology of Socrates by Plato Full Audiobook with Text, Illustrations"
- by Audiobooks Dimension

Full text translation

Relevant web pages 

Some questions for discussion

To be added.

Sunday, 7 July 2024

Euthyphro

 
"Euthyphro by Plato Audiobook with Text, Illustrations" - by Audiobooks Dimension

Full text translation

    The Euthyphro Dilemma

    The Euthyphro dilemma is found on page 7 in the following text of the Euthyphro:


    The Euthyphro Dilemma and Devine Command Theory


    The Euthyphro Dilemma: Religion and Morality (Divine Command Theory
    by teachphilosophy

    Please find more discussion on the Euthyphro Dilemma and the Divine Command Theory in this article in the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

    Some questions for discussion

    1. When was the dialogue written? Was it written soon after Socrates' trial?
    2. Do you think the dialogue is fictional?
    3. What are the main philosophical concepts being explored?
    4. What rhetorical devices are demonstrated in the dialogue?
    5. What is the Euthyphro dilemma?
    6. When did Plato write the early, middle and late dialogues?
    7. Does natural law theory solve the problem presented by the Euthyphro Dilemma?
    8. What might Socrates and Euthyphro represent in terms of our self reflection?
    9. What might piety mean in our lives today, and will we be able to answer Socrates' question?
    10. Given the Euthyphro Dilemma and other challenges to the Divine Command Theory, do you think the theory is still a reasonable theory for one to adopt?
    Please see possible answers here.

    Relevant web pages 

    Socratic method

     

    Socratic Method of Philosophizing - by PHILO-notes on YouTube

    Some YouTube videos

    The video above gives a brief explanation of the Socratic method.  The following YouTube videos provide a more detail explanation of the method.

    Socrates and the Socratic Method of Critical Thinking - by Critical Thinking Professor Kerckhove - https://youtu.be/46CYtwXH_aE?si=rvRBwqIL4KhNgtMg

     Lecture Socrates in Action, The Euthyphro - https://youtu.be/LNz9K2JwGGQ?si=yjoeZQU_As0Seugr

    Some web pages  

    Britannica - Socratic method - https://www.britannica.com/topic/Socratic-method

    Wikipedia - Socratic method - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socratic_method

     

    Wednesday, 3 July 2024

    Socrates

     

    "If Everyone Believes It, It's Probably Wrong - The Philosophy of Socrates (& Plato)"
    by Pursuit of Wonder on YouTube

    Introduction to Socrates

    The YouTube video above gives an introduction to Socrates the Philosopher.

    Some questions for discussion

    1. What are the main philosophical ideas of Socrates?
    2. What did Socrates mean when he said: “I know that I know nothing”?
    3. Why is Socrates an important philosopher and known as the father of Western philosophy?
    4. Why did Socrates deliberately question and challenge his fellow citizens, despite knowing that he would upset them?
    5. Socrates upset many important Athenian citizens and was sentenced to death.  Was Socrates courageous or foolish?
    6. How does Socrates’ philosophy relate to Plato’s?
    7. What is the Socratic problem?
    8. Socrates had many admirers but also many enemies. If you were an Athenian citizen at the time, would you like Socrates as a friend or teacher or would you find him annoying?
    9. What is the Socratic method?
    10. What is Socratic irony?

    Some web pages on Socrates

    The following web pages provide write-ups on Socrates:

    Britannica - https://www.britannica.com/biography/Socrates 

    Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy - https://iep.utm.edu/socrates/ 

     Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy - https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/socrates/

    Sunday, 12 November 2023

    Plato's Phaedo


    Phaedo by Plato | Audiobook with Text
    by Chillbooks


    Phaedo, also known to ancient readers as On The Soul, is one of the best-known dialogues of Plato's middle period, along with the Republic and the Symposium. The philosophical subject of the dialogue is the immortality of the soul. It is set in the last hours prior to the death of Socrates, and is Plato's fourth and last dialogue to detail the philosopher's final days, following Euthyphro, Apology, and Crito.




    Thursday, 9 November 2023

    The Allegory of the Chariot, and how it relates to the Theory of Forms

     

    Plato and the Soul - Demizmue

    The Allegory of the Chariot

    The video above explains Plato's Allegory of the Chariot, which describes the soul figuratively as a chariot, driven by a charioteer, and powered by two horses: a noble white horse and an ignoble dark one.

    The Allegory and how it relates to the Theory of Forms

    The Google slide document here shows some diagrams that explain the following concepts that were  discussed recently:
    • Roger Penrose's 3 Worlds
    • Political discussion vs philosophical discussion
    • Plato's Theory of Forms
    • The Ladder of Love
    • The Allegory of the Chariot

    Plato's ethics

    The following videos provide an overview of Plato's idea on ethics and link many of the ideas discussed earlier:

    Plato's Ethics (A History of Western Thought 13) - by Dr. Jordan B Cooper
     
    PHILOSOPHY: Platonic Ethics - Angie Hobbs 
    https://youtu.be/QJ-I3MKtcnc?si=ky2QrMNMciKzUarV 


    Saturday, 28 October 2023

    Plato's The Symposium


    The Symposium by PLATO (FULL Audiobook) translated by Benjamin Jowett
     by Audio Books

    The Symposium is considered one of Plato's most important works.  It puts forward important philosophical concepts and is also fun to read.

    You can find write ups on it from the following sites:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symposium_(Plato)

    https://www.sparknotes.com/philosophy/symposium/

    A pdf copy of The Symposium can be found here:  The Symposium by Benjamin Jowett

     

    Thursday, 26 October 2023

    Platonic Relationship

     


    The Ladder of Love: Plato's Symposium
    by PhilosophyToons

    Platonic Relationship

    A platonic relationship is a close friendship between two individuals without sexual or romantic involvement ¹². The term "platonic" comes from the ancient Greek philosopher Plato, who wrote about different types of love in his works ¹. Plato believed that love could be divided into two categories: physical and spiritual ³. He believed that physical love was inferior to spiritual love, which he considered to be the highest form of love ³. Platonic love was one of the types of spiritual love that Plato wrote about, and he believed that it could bring individuals closer to a sacred ideal ³.

    In modern times, the term "platonic relationship" is used to describe a relationship that is based on deep love for another person, but lacks romantic or sexual aspects ¹. The relationship is based on emotional connections and mutual interests, without any sexual or romantic involvement ⁴. 

    Platonic relationships can be formed between people of any gender and sexual orientation ¹. They can be very fulfilling and provide a sense of companionship and support without the complications of romantic relationships .

    Source: Conversation with Bing, 26/10/2023

    (1) What Is a Platonic Relationship? - Verywell Mind. https://www.verywellmind.com/what-is-a-platonic-relationship-5185281.

    (2) What Is A Platonic Relationship? - Simply Psychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/what-is-a-platonic-relationship.html.

    (3) What It Means to Have Platonic Love - Psych Central. https://psychcentral.com/relationships/platonic-relationship.

    (4) 6 Types of Relationships and Their Effect on Your Life - Verywell Mind. https://www.verywellmind.com/6-types-of-relationships-and-their-effect-on-your-life-5209431.

     

    What Is the 'Ladder of Love' in Plato's 'Symposium'?

    Please see below for an article by Professor Emrys Westacott on Plato's Ladder of Love:

    The "ladder of love" occurs in the text Symposium (c. 385-370 BC) by the ancient Greek philosopher Plato. It's about a contest at a men's banquet, involving impromptu philosophical speeches in praise of Eros, the Greek god of love and sexual desire. Socrates summarized the speeches of five of the guests and then recounted the teachings of a priestess, Diotima. The ladder is a metaphor for the ascent a lover might make from purely physical attraction to something beautiful, as a beautiful body, the lowest rung, to actual contemplation of the Form of Beauty itself.

    Diotima maps out the stages in this ascent in terms of what sort of beautiful thing the lover desires and is drawn toward.

        1. A particular beautiful body. This is the starting point, when love, which by definition is a desire for something we don’t have, is first aroused by the sight of individual beauty.
        2. All beautiful bodies. According to standard Platonic doctrine, all beautiful bodies share something in common, something the lover eventually comes to recognize. When he does recognize this, he moves beyond a passion for any particular body.
        3. Beautiful souls. Next, the lover comes to realize that spiritual and moral beauty matters much more than physical beauty. So he will now yearn for the sort of interaction with noble characters that will help him become a better person.
        4. Beautiful laws and institutions. These are created by good people (beautiful souls) and are the conditions which foster moral beauty.
        5. The beauty of knowledge. The lover turns his attention to all kinds of knowledge, but particularly, in the end to philosophical understanding. (Although the reason for this turn isn’t stated, it is presumably because philosophical wisdom is what underpins good laws and institutions.)
        6. Beauty itself – that is, the Form of the Beautiful. This is described as "an everlasting loveliness which neither comes nor goes, which neither flowers nor fades." It is the very essence of beauty, "subsisting of itself and by itself in an eternal oneness." And every particular beautiful thing is beautiful because of its connection to this Form.  The lover who has ascended the ladder apprehends the Form of Beauty in a kind of vision or revelation, not through words or in the way that other sorts of more ordinary knowledge are known.

      Diotima tells Socrates that if he ever reached the highest rung on the ladder and contemplated the Form of Beauty, he would never again be seduced by the physical attractions of beautiful youths. Nothing could make life more worth living than enjoying this sort of vision. Because the Form of Beauty is perfect, it will inspire perfect virtue in those who contemplate it.

      This account of the ladder of love is the source for the familiar notion of "Platonic love," by which is meant the sort of love that is not expressed through sexual relations. The description of the ascent can be viewed as an account of sublimation, the process of transforming one sort of impulse into another, usually, one that is viewed as "higher" or more valuable. In this instance, the sexual desire for a beautiful body becomes sublimated into a desire for philosophical understanding and insight.

      Citation: Westacott, Emrys. "What Is the 'Ladder of Love' in Plato's 'Symposium'?" ThoughtCo, Aug. 28, 2020, thoughtco.com/platos-ladder-of-love-2670661.

      Plato's Theory of Forms

       

      from PHILO-notes

      Theory of Forms

      Plato's theory of forms is a philosophical idea that suggests there are two realms of existence: the visible world and the intelligible world. The visible world is the one we perceive with our senses, and it is full of changing and imperfect things. The intelligible world is the one we access with our reason, and it is composed of eternal and perfect forms. These forms are the essences or ideals of everything that exists in the visible world, such as beauty, justice, goodness, etc. Plato believed that the forms are the only true objects of knowledge, and that we can only approach them through rational inquiry.

      One way to illustrate Plato's theory of forms is by using his famous allegory of the cave¹. Imagine a group of prisoners who have been chained in a dark cave since birth. They can only see the shadows of objects projected on the wall by a fire behind them. They think that these shadows are the reality, and they have no idea that there is a world outside the cave. One day, one of the prisoners escapes and sees the real objects that cast the shadows. He also sees the sun, which is the source of light and truth. He returns to the cave and tries to tell his fellow prisoners what he has seen, but they do not believe him and think he is crazy.

      Plato used this allegory to show that most people are like the prisoners in the cave, who only see the appearances of things and not their true forms. They are deceived by their senses and opinions, and they do not seek the higher knowledge that comes from reason. Only a few people, like the escaped prisoner, are able to free themselves from their ignorance and reach the intelligible world, where they can contemplate the forms. These people are the philosophers, who Plato considered to be the best rulers for a just society.

      I hope this gives you a brief overview of Plato's theory of forms. If you want to learn more about it, you can read some of his dialogues that discuss it, such as Phaedo, Symposium, Republic, or Timaeus. You can also check out some of these links for more information:

      • [Theory of forms - Wikipedia]: A detailed article on Plato's theory of forms, with references and sources.

      Source: Conversation with Bing, 26/10/2023

      (1) Theory of forms - Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_forms.

      (2) Plato's Theory of Forms | Definition, Examples & Analysis - Perlego. 

      (3) Plato’s Allegory of the Cave and Theory of the Forms Explained.

      Daodejing verses relating to leadership

       The following are some verses in Daodejing relating to leadership. Chapter Two -  The nourishment of the person  [1]   是以聖人處無為之事,行不言之教; 萬物作...