Tuesday, 26 April 2022

Should he kill the fat man?

At the last class in term 1 on 6/4/22, we had fun discussing the scenario called "Should he kill the fat man?" in the following website.

https://www.philosophyexperiments.com/

The following were the voting results in class that day compare to other people , shown as % in ( ), using the website.

                                                                                                    YES                        NO

1. Is torture is always wrong?                                                 8 votes (65%)          0 vote  (35%)

2. Should we maximize happiness?                                        5 votes (48%)          3 votes (52%)

3. Is it always wrong to cause another person's death?          8 votes (59%)          0 vote (41%)

4. Should we save lives of innocent people?                          8 votes (77%)          0 vote (23%)    

5. Should he turn the train (kill 1 to save 5 people)                 7 votes                     0 vote

6. Should he push the fat man to save 5 people?                   0 votes                     8 votes

7. Should he push the fat saboteur onto the track?                 5 votes                     3 votes  

8 Should he torture the fat man to save many lives?               8 votes                     0 votes



Daodejing - Chapter Forty Nine

  道德經  - 第四十九章 聖人無常心,以百姓心為心。 善者,吾善之;不善者,吾亦善之;德善。 信者,吾信之;不信者,吾亦信之;德信。 聖人在天下,歙歙為天下渾其心, 百姓皆注其耳目,聖人皆孩之。 Daodejing - Chapter Forty Nine (The qual...